The Environment Agency rated Southern Water with one star as “poor performing” in its 2025 Environmental Performance Assessment, published on 29 October 2026.

The regulator’s company report gave Southern Water red status on four of six measures and green status on two. It recorded 12 serious pollution incidents from the company’s assets and 253 category 1 to 3 incidents from its sewerage network during 2025.

Southern Water said the result was “disappointing but expected” and reflected the challenge of operating ageing infrastructure during extreme weather and intense rainfall. Dame Caroline Dinenage, the Conservative MP for Gosport, challenged the company’s leadership in a letter reported by The News; Hampshire Minute has not seen the letter.

Eight of the 12 serious incidents came from rising mains, two from foul sewers, one from a pumping station and one from a sewage treatment works, according to the Environment Agency. The total of 253 incidents amounted to 64 per 10,000km of sewer, compared with a sector average of 41. Southern Water would have needed 77 or fewer incidents for a green rating on that measure.

The company also received one star in 2013, 2019 and 2021. The Environment Agency’s rating history said Southern Water had mostly been rated one or two stars since 2011.

Dinenage wrote to chief executive Lawrence Gosden after the assessment appeared, according to The News. She said people in Gosport, Stubbington, Lee-on-the-Solent and Hill Head expected their coastline to be protected and that their patience was “wearing thin”. She told Gosden that the public would judge his leadership by whether the company’s turnaround plan produced change.

Tim McMahon, Southern Water’s chief operating officer, said the company had cut pollution incidents by almost a third since 2023, reduced external sewer flooding by 18 per cent and leakage by 12 per cent. He said an £8.9bn investment programme was addressing the causes of pollution but that change would not happen overnight.

The assessment followed a unanimous vote of no confidence in Southern Water by Havant Borough Council on 7 October. The council asked the Environment Secretary, Ofwat and the Environment Agency to inspect the Budds Farm wastewater works and Havant Thicket reservoir site. It also asked the Planning Inspectorate to pause or reconsider the company’s application to recycle treated effluent through the reservoir.

The regulators’ first joint Water Industry Performance Insights report, also published on 29 October, recorded 2,991 pollution incidents across England and Wales in 2025, including 84 serious incidents. It said pollution remained one of the sector’s main areas of concern.